• HOME
  • Aircraft
    • AIRFRAMES
      • Proud to fly a Turboprop: Q400 vs ATR72
      • Airbus A320 Experience
    • SYSTEMS
      • Pratt and Whitney PW1100G Geared Turbofan Engine
      • Winglets and Sharklets
      • Cockpit Design: EPR v/s N1 indication
      • Boeing’s MAX, Southwest’s 737
      • GPS to the rescue!
    • ACCIDENTS AND INCIDENTS
      • LOT 767 Gear Up Landing
      • Iran Air 743:Partial Gear Up Landing
  • AIRLINE
    • ANALYSIS
      • IndiGo performs well in Q3’16, but is outshone by Q1’16
      • SpiceJet: Q1’16 Operational Financials Forecast
      • Vistara – Review & Analysis
      • AirAsia India – Q2FY15 performance and outlook
      • Q2 results and Prof. Sanjiv Kapoor’s introductory class on Airline Economics
      • SpiceJet in Q(2) – Great Performance in Testing Times.
      • Could SpiceJet have been profitable in FY2013-14?
      • Interlysis – AirAsia India and Mrithyunjaya Chandilya
      • A glimpse of Tony’s AirAsia India, and his success mantra
      • Interlysis with Shyson Thomas – Air Pegasus, Unplugged.
    • EVENTS
      • AirAsia India-and the competition-gets real
      • Spicejet’s inaugural Bangalore-Bangkok Run
      • Spicejet unveils the Q400s
    • HUMAN FACTORS
      • Dissatisfied Flightcrew
      • Love is in “the air”
      • Captain Dad and kid First Officer
      • Cathay’s Young Cabin Crew!
  • AVIATION
    • The Indian Aviation 2015 growth story deciphered
    • National Civil Aviation Policy 2015
      • Safety
      • Regional Connectivity Scheme (RCS)
      • The 5/20 Rule
      • Route Dispersal Guidelines
      • Scheduled Commuter Airlines (SCAs)
      • Aviation Education & Skill Development
    • 2014: A year flown by
    • 2013: A year flown by
    • Training
      • Familiarization Flights for ATCOs
      • A320 FFS LOFT Session
      • HINDUSTAN GROUP OF INSTITUTIONS: AN AVIATION UNIVERSITY
        • Hindustan Institute of Engineering and Technology (HIET)
        • Hindustan Institute of Technology & Science (HITS): Hindustan University
        • Orient Flight School (OFS)
      • IGRUA
      • NFTI: Rising to the Top, and how
      • Aerospace Engineering in India: the Gaps
      • Chief Flying Instructors
    • PEOPLE
      • Radka Máchová
      • Rodrigo David: The man behind some of the best A320 flightdeck videos
    • TECHNOLOGY
      • GAGAN: India’s first step to a Future Air Navigation System (FANS)
  • PROJECTS
    • AIRBUS TECH
      • About PAT
      • AIRCON/PRESSURIZATION/VENTILATION
      • AUTOFLIGHT
      • COMMUNICATION SYSTEMS
      • ELECTRICAL SYSTEMS
      • FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEMS
      • FLIGHT CONTROLS
      • FUEL SYSTEMS
      • HYDRAULIC SYSTEMS
      • ICE AND RAIN PROTECTION
      • LANDING GEAR
      • LIGHTS
      • OXYGEN
      • PNEUMATICS
      • APU
      • DOORS
      • POWER PLANT (IAE)
    • ATR9X
      • About ATR 9X
      • Logbook
      • Introduction
      • Fuselage
    • General Aviation Flight Simulator
    • Dual Cyliner Rotax Electronic Engine-Kill Switch
    • Making a Lynx Micro Headset Charger on the Go!
  • ABOUT
    • About The Flying Engineer
    • Advertising
    • Merchandise

The Flying Engineer

~ Technically and Operationally Commercial Aviation

The Flying Engineer

Tag Archives: Growth

Deciphering the 2015 Indian Aviation growth story

02 Tuesday Feb 2016

Posted by theflyingengineer in Airline

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

2015, Aviation, Domestic, Growth, India

Chart 1

The year 2015 has been a remarkable year for Indian domestic aviation. The growth in domestic passenger numbers, and the start of many new airlines, has undoubtedly led everyone to believe that 2015 is the third boom in Indian aviation.

But how did 2015 register a strong 20% growth in domestic passengers? Was it mere addition of capacity, or was it more? What triggered the growth? This and more, when you click here.

Is the Indian ‘Middle Class’ of 300 Million ready to fly?

05 Thursday Nov 2015

Posted by theflyingengineer in Airline, Aviation

≈ 3 Comments

Tags

300, Aviation. Draft, Civil, DGCA, Growth, Million, Ministry, Passenger, Policy, population

NCAP 2015 Regional Aviation India

Everyone today looks upto India as the next destination for growth. The Ministry of Civil Aviation, in its draft National Civil Aviation Policy, has captured the attention of everyone with the claim of a large middle class population, and the promise of certain reforms that should may better the ease of doing business.

We appreciate what the Ministry has done, is doing, and will do. But certain claims must be taken with a pinch of salt, must be questioned, and analysed, just to prevent over-optimism and to make room for realism. Like for example:

  1. India is a 300 million strong population of middle class persons. The Ministry targets each of these 300 million to fly atleast once in their life. Pertinent questions: What is the definition of middle class? What subset can really afford air travel? These questions are important to prevent overcapacity in the Indian market based on optimism.
  2. India targets 300 million domestic ticketing by 2022. That means, calendar year (CY) 2021 must end with 300 million domestic passengers in a single year. India will end CY 2015 with 80 million domestic passengers. What is the compound annual growth rate (CAGR) required to touch 300 million in CY 2021? Is this CAGR too high to achive? What do market leaders like Airbus say?

Today, we focus on these two issues, which form part of the Ministry’s vision, and we see if this is achievable. Our views on the Regional Connectivity Scheme and the 5/20 are ready, which we hope to release tomorrow. We will also be commenting on Scheduled Commuter Airlines (SCA) and Safety, and lightly touch upon Aeronautical ‘Make in India’, Aviation Education & Skill Development, and Air Navigation Services.

To read about the first two issues, please click here.

SpiceJet: Another New Version

06 Saturday Jun 2015

Posted by theflyingengineer in SpiceJet

≈ 1 Comment

Tags

Growth, operational, profit, Q4, Spicejet

SG737

10 year old SpiceJet’s performance in Q4 FY’15 has been promising. SpiceJet as an airline has been promising in certain quarters, profitable in some others, and disappointing in many. One problem that has plagued the airline is impatience. The constant change of top management results in one, big problem: insufficient time for any strategy to bear fruits, no matter how brilliant.

That is because any strategy has a trial and error phase – essential to coarse and fine tune the strategy to the environment – both internal and external to the airline.

In Q4’FY15, SpiceJet changed hands, yet again. The Marans are out, and Ajay Singh is back in. In the quarter, the aircraft lost a Q400 to an accident at Hubli. Active fleet size was down to 17 Boeing 737s and 13 Q400s – a total of 30 airplanes, down 50% from the days of 57.

Things got so complicated at the airline that the one element required to run an airline was missing – Simplicity.

Operational Numbers

SG_op_Q4

The circumstances surrounding the airline, and the situation it was in Q4’FY15 was very different from what was in Q4’FY14. Yet, comparison is worthy to put things in perspective.

Q4’FY15 saw SpiceJet as a shrunk airline – lesser routes, smaller fleet, lesser departures. The number of flights were lower by 43%, to an average 179 a day from 312 in Q4’FY14. Load factor difference was a positive by 13% – which meant the airline carried more passengers per flight, on average. This had two effects – the number of passengers carried was down only 37% despite 43% lesser flights. This also affected the cargo uplift, which was down 8% due to lesser free cargo space available. The average flight length was 752 km – down 9% from 826km. Capacity was down 52%.

SpiceJet is yet to stabilise its operations. An airline has two aims: safe and convenient flights for passengers, and value for shareholders. Part of convenience are frequency and on time performance, with the latter more important.

SpiceJet’s on time performance isn’t one of the best, and that is something that the airline needs to, and perhaps is, working on. SpiceJet has had the highest number of cancellations among all airlines in the month of January and March, and the second highest among established airlines in the month fo February. Stabilisation of such operational parameters is key to SpiceJet becoming a preferred airline.

Down to the rupee

SG_RASK_CASK change_Q4

Unit revenues speak volumes about an airline’s efficiency.

We look only into Income from operations (Net sales), and ignore all other incomes, as this is the real measure of the airline’s core activity’s performance.

Q4’15 had a revenue of INR 4.15/seat-km (or per ASK= RASK), which is 3% higher than what was realised last year. This shows that the increase in load factors had a positive impact on unit revenues, thanks to the strategies employed by the former CCO Kaneswaran Avili and the VP Revenue Management Fares Kilpady. This also reflects network rationalisation.

When an airline shrinks, costs get complicated. There are certain costs that are hard to shrink, such as employee costs, as layoffs are subject to an airline’s culture. Employee costs per ASK shot up 63% to INR 0.57/seat-km. Further, staff salaries were upward revised after Q4’14.

Although the airline shrunk its fleet, it were the leased Boeing 737s that moved out, not the owned Q400s. Capacity dropped, but the depreciation and amortisation costs associated with the aircraft didn’t. This resulted in the associated costs rising by 48% to INR 0.16/seat-km.

Airport charges went up by 18%, in part due to the reduced flight lengths, which means the airline had more take off and landings for the same capacity. This may have also negatively impacted aircraft maintenance. Spares pool policy may have also had an impact. If an aircraft went for a C-check in this period, costs may have been impacted too. Maintenance costs per ASK went up 3%.

Other operating costs went up 17% to INR 0.16/seat-km.

Other expenses, which includes administrative expenses went down by 5%.

Lease rentals per unit went down 18% to INR 0.61/seat-km, owing to higher utilisation of aircraft which diluted this fixed cost.

Aircraft fuel costs went down 31% to INR 1.52/seat-km largely due to the fall of ATF prices.

Fuel, Maintenance, Staff, Lease and amortisation (as Q400s are owned, and is the equivalent of lease costs) and other operating expenses form a chunk of the expenses, and these 5 together account for 92% of expenses. These costs together went down by 12% to INR 3.62/seat-km in Q4’15 against INR 4.13/seat-km in Q4’14.

Redelivery expenses are one-off expenses and went up 626% to INR 0.35/seat-km. Other expenses are arguably not part of the operating expense consideration set.

With this, the operational cost per available seat kilometre (which excludes one-off redelivery costs and administrative ‘other expenses’) is INR 3.98/seat-km, which is 10% lower than the INR 4.44/seat-km in Q4’14.

With an operational RASK of INR 4.15/seat-km, and an arguable operational CASK of INR 3.98/seat-km, the airline was arguably operationally profitable by INR 0.16/seat-km.

Core operating costs and revenues are stressed upon as this is a reflection of the performance and efficiency of an airline’s core activity. However, an airline will need to be efficient throughout the structure. SpiceJet realised a loss of INR 102 Cr due to the total operating RASK and total operating CASK amounting to INR 4.15/seat-km and INR 4.71/seat-km, respectively.

Extraordinary Income and bottom line

Insurance companies paid INR 161 Cr for the Q400 that was written off after an accident at Hubli, Karnataka. SpiceJet received INR 61 Cr. This, along with other income of 91 Cr added INR 153 Cr to the books. Finance costs drained INR 28 Cr. Overall operating loss drained INR 102 Cr.

The airline realised a net profit of INR 22 Cr, and the insurance pay off was responsible for the tip over into the black.

Comparison with AirAsia India

SG_vs_I5_Q4

While a comparison between a small start-up airline and a larger, older airline is fair to neither airline, a comparison will help show what’s possible.

Unit costs (per seat-km) of staff is leaner at SpiceJet as it is a larger airline, however, this can fall further. SpiceJet cannot escape amortisation & depreciation costs as Q400s are owned, while AirAsia only leases airplanes. Fuel expenses per ASK are higher at SpiceJet due to the higher fuel burn per ASK of the Q400, the possibility of higher burns due to ATC congestion at metros, and higher load factors.

All of AirAsia’s airplanes in Q4 were new, and almost fresh out of maintenance when delivered, needing hardly any maintenance. Such may not have been the case at SpiceJet, which could have taken up the maintenance cost up.

User charges are higher at SpiceJet as AirAsia India does enjoy certain benefits from Bangalore airport – the only airport it used to fly into in Q4. SpiceJet flew into all metros.

Aircraft operating lease expenses appear lower at SpiceJet as of the 30 aircraft in the fleet, only 17 were leased. Q400’s lease costs do not figure in the lease expenses.

Other operating expenses are lower at SpiceJet due to a larger fleet diluting costs. However, ‘other operating costs’ for SpiceJet may not be the same as AirAsia India’s.

Where SpiceJet can trim its cost are in the ‘other expenses’. However, AirAsia India has lower administrative costs as many resources are shared with the AirAsia Group.

The cost structure (see pie charts) of both airlines show the cost structure for both airlines. Generally, a cost structure which has a larger share of fuel cost indicates a leaner structure.

Cost_structure_SG_I5

A chance to renew

What the management did in FY 2014-2015 to SpiceJet has been impressive – revenue management and market stimulation has resulted in a positive impact on unit revenues even with higher load factors and promotional fares. Such practice, if continued, may benefit the airline in the current fiscal.

The airline scaled up its fleet in Q1’16 temporarily through the wet-lease of 3 Boeing 737s. Unverified information point to 2 additional Q400s joining the fleet, and an active evaluation of wet-leasing Airbus A320 aircraft. Whatever the aircraft type, and however questionable it may be, the airline is going to, and needs to increase its fleet size.

SpiceJet has another opportunity to keep the system lean as it regrows. Good contracts, scaling up and high asset utilisation will reduce fixed costs. Good market study, prudent and well researched network growth, leveraging the benefits of the Q400 to do what the market leader cannot, and differentiation of in-flight services can allow SpiceJet to realise good unit revenues even in the light of competition.

Revenues aren’t much of a problem at SpiceJet, but can be bettered through better core service – frequency and on time performance. Costs are the biggest problem in the airline, and will need to be trimmed down significantly.

SpiceJet has what it takes to grow to an extent that allows it to compete non-head-on and healthily with the market leader. Focus on basics and differentiation are key.

ATR: Quietly growing: Operators, Training, Maintenance & Support.

16 Wednesday Oct 2013

Posted by theflyingengineer in Manufacturer

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

42, 500, 600, 72, ATR, Growth

ATR_OP_SE_AsiaATR has proved in recent years to be successful in South East Asia, a market which experiences strong development of its regional networks. Since 2005, ATR has sold over 170 new firm aircraft to South East Asian carriers, accounting for 98% of all regional aircraft with up to 90 seats sold in the region during this period.

Garuda Indonesia, the flag carrier of Indonesia, is expanding its fleet with a firm commitment to lease 25 ATR 72-600s, with options for 10 more, from Nordic Aviation Capital (NAC), based in Billund, Denmark. NAC, in June 2013, placed an order for 90 ATR aircraft, including ATR 42-600s. With this, the leasing company’s ATR fleet grows to 150 aircraft. Garuda Indonesia joins Indonesian Lion Air’s subsidiary, Wings Air, as an ATR operator. Wings Air is ATR’s largest customer for the ATR 72s. Together with Garuda/s ATR 72s, Indonesia alone will may have more than 100 ATR 72 aircraft in the next two years. Some of these ATRs make their way to Lion Group’s Malindo.

Malaysia Airlines and ATR inked a deal in late 2012 for the purchase of a total of 36 ATR 72-600s (20 firm orders plus 16 options) to be operated by the airline’s regional subsidiaries, MASwings and Firefly. The two subsidiaries have started receiving their ATR 72-600 aircraft.

Myannmar’s Air KBZ, which already operated ATR 72-500s, received two ATR 72-600s this year.

ATR-27192_BDATR opened its Flight Training Centre at Singapore on the 14th of December 2013. With more than 250 ATR aircraft flying in the Asia-Pacific region, with 50 operators, it was only prudent to bring a training centre closer to a region of high significance.

Just months after the training centre was opened, the simulator is running at full capacity. With the encouraging response, ATR has chosen to open another training center, this time in partnership with an ATR operator, Avianca, in Bogota.

ATR penetrated Japan with Link, an operator that plans to start operations by the end of 2013. Link will acquire three ATR 72-600s, becoming the first carrier in Japan to operate ATR aircraft.

The 50th edition of the Paris Air Show was the best in the history of the Franco-Italian aircraft manufacturer ATR. Over the course of the week, the turboprop aircraft manufacturer announced orders for 173 planes, including 83 firm orders at the air show. The order book also ensures ATR’s production until the end of 2016.

Maintenance Expansion: India.

As part of the steadily planned expansion of the ATR MRO Network, ATR, on 11th October, called for tenders to initiate the selection process of an ATR MRO Network member in India to cover the geographical region.

Shifting Markets & Support.

During the show, ATR announced orders from markets which have proved among the most promising in recent years: the aircraft leasing companies and Latin America. This has prompted ATR to shift its office in North America. “Across Latin and South America, we are seeing a big rise in the sheer number of ATRs in service, as we win over new operators and current clients increase the number of turboprops in their fleets. So it makes sense for us to relocate our North America office to Miami to be close to all our customers across the whole of the Americas”, says Filippo Bagnato, Chief Executive Officer, ATR.

Referred by:

Referred by:

Project:

Project:

In Depth Articles:

In Depth Articles:

In Depth Articles:

RSS Feed

RSS Feed RSS - Posts

RSS Feed RSS - Comments

The Flying Engineer’s tweets

  • Couldn't have asked for a more glorious end. https://t.co/f9NYJgxYCL 1 week ago
  • Some hold the emergency door open. Regardless. twitter.com/mhdksafa/statu… 1 week ago
  • Embraer twitter.com/BrothaManBlack… 1 week ago
  • RT @jamiebsmith: Legroom is on point. Absolutely love the Embraer jets. https://t.co/wNpTJXm7uQ 1 week ago
  • @unraveaero @aditishahsays @AirLeaseCorp @Reuters @Airbus @Boeing Exactly what was on my mind but refrained from co… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 1 week ago
Follow @TheFlyingEnggnr

Visit our Facebook Page

Visit our Facebook Page

Blog archives of The Flying Engineer

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 17,608 other subscribers

Site Statistics

  • 2,447,321 views

Top Posts & Pages

  • Pratt and Whitney PW1100G Geared Turbofan Engine
    Pratt and Whitney PW1100G Geared Turbofan Engine
  • Winglets and Sharklets
    Winglets and Sharklets
  • Cockpit Design: EPR v/s N1 indication
    Cockpit Design: EPR v/s N1 indication
  • Proud to fly a Turboprop: Q400 vs ATR72
    Proud to fly a Turboprop: Q400 vs ATR72
  • On the A320 Neo, if you're unlucky, you've got the last row
    On the A320 Neo, if you're unlucky, you've got the last row
  • Vision, Mission and Objectives
    Vision, Mission and Objectives
  • FUEL SYSTEMS
    FUEL SYSTEMS
  • HYDRAULIC SYSTEMS
    HYDRAULIC SYSTEMS
  • AIRCON/PRESSURIZATION/VENTILATION
    AIRCON/PRESSURIZATION/VENTILATION
  • AUTOFLIGHT
    AUTOFLIGHT

Recent Posts!

  • IndiGo receives its first Airbus A320neo at Toulouse
  • On the A320 Neo, if you’re unlucky, you’ve got the last row
  • Why the FIA’s case against the removal of the 5/20 rule is unjustified
  • Why the 90 seat Q400 had to be announced at the Singapore Air Show
  • Analysing IndiGo’s performance in Q3’16
  • Deciphering the 2015 Indian Aviation growth story
  • Air Costa receives its third Embraer E190 at Jordan
  • Why Jet Airways meant much for Brussels
  • Same aircraft family, different hands: Boeing 737NG flown by the Air Force and an airline
  • IndiGo to fly India’s longest daily domestic flight effective 7th January 2016

Blog at WordPress.com.

  • Follow Following
    • The Flying Engineer
    • Join 393 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • The Flying Engineer
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...